Critical thinking

Joseph Reagle

Critical thinking

Critical thinking is a process of hunting assumptions—discovering what assumptions we and others hold, and then checking to see how much sense those assumptions make. (Brookfield 2012, “Teaching for critical thinking”)

How?

  1. look from multiple viewpoints
  2. be sensitive to ideologies (tacit economic, political, and social values)
  3. appreciate different types of assumptions
  4. be aware of thinking errors
  5. look for falsifying evidence

Thinking errors

A Quick Puzzle

Confirmation bias: We look for evidence that confirms our beliefs/theories rather than challenging them.

Why critical thinking?

So as to take informed action.

actions that are grounded in evidence, can be explained to others, and stand a good chance of achieving the results we desire. (Brookfield 2012, “Teaching for critical thinking”)

Spurious correlation

cage vs pool drowning

Shark attacks vs ice-cream consumption??

Correlation != Causation

Spot the errors?

This critical thinking video has critical thinking fails.

Other cognitive biases

Also

Street epistemology

collaborative and respectful exploration of reasoning

Lateral thinking

traditional vs. lateral thinking

Review

Quiz

  • In the NYT quiz we did, which sequence would be a good test of the rule that the numbers are ascending powers of two?
  • What critical thinking principle does the exercise demonstrate?
  • The shark exercising demonstrates the important of what critical thinking principle?