Authenticity, audience, and context collapse

Joseph Reagle

Questions

Context and code switching

The different Dollies

Work laugh

Clinton’s Changing Accents

Obamas’ fist bump

New Yorker cover

Did Trump “code switch”?

Background

Symbolic interactionism

meaning in action, is polysemous, and changes

Symbolic interactionism

How a person makes and enacts meaning (via interpretation) resulting from interaction.

identity and self are constituted through constant interactions with others – primarily, talk. Individuals work together to uphold preferred self-images of themselves and their conversation partners, through strategies like maintaining (or “saving”) face, collectively encouraging social norms, or negotiating power differentials and disagreements. (Marwickboyd 2011, p. 144)

Dramaturgy

A branch of symbolic interactionism that focuses on everyday life via the metaphor of the stage. Goffman argued that we wish to have our “audience” accept our presentation of self. It includes concepts such as:

Celebrity

Celebrity

Celebrity is a dynamic performative practice rather than personal characteristic or external label (e.g., being on American Idol) (Marwickboyd 2011, p. 140)

Micro-celebrity

… involves viewing friends or followers as a fan base; acknowledging popularity as a goal; managing the fan base using a variety of affiliative techniques; and constructing an image of self that can be easily consumed… (Marwickboyd 2011, p. 141)

… [is] being famous to a niche group of people, but it is also a behavior: the presentation of oneself as a celebrity regardless of who is paying attention. (Marwick 2013, “Status update”, p. 114)

Micro vs Macro

[micro-celebrity techniques] resemble techniques that extremely famous people use to manage audiences on Twitter, rather than relying on formal access brokers like managers and agents to maintain the distance between themselves and fans. (Marwickboyd 2011, p. 141)

Micro-celebrity?

Which of these are examples of micro-celebrity vs. meme-fame?

  1. Star Wars Kid (rotoscoped)
  2. Baby Frogs
  3. PlaneBae

“I Tweet Honestly”

Worlds colliding

Framing?

  1. What is (Marwickboyd 2010) main question/thesis?
  2. Methodology?

Framing

“To whom was I speaking?”?

Concepts

ex. gDoc

For each item from (Marwickboyd 2010)

Tasks: groups of 5

  1. Ideology of publicity
  2. Impression management
  3. Context collapse
  4. Authenticity
  5. Networked audience

Discussion

Comparing platforms??

Zuck & integrity

“You have one identity,” [Zuckerberg] says emphatically three times in a single minute during a 2009 interview […] “The days of you having a different image for your work friends or co-workers and for the other people you know are probably coming to an end pretty quickly,” he says […] “Having two identities for yourself is an example of a lack of integrity,” […] “the level of transparency the world has now won’t support having two identities for a person.” (Kirkpatrick 2010, “The Facebook effect”, p. 199)

…only has himself to blame

“Facebook Is Worried About Users Sharing Less – But It Only Has Itself To Blame Technology” (Hoffmann 2016)

Conclusion

Wrap up

Review

What is?

Ideology of publicity
we value whatever grabs the public’s attention
Impression management
we perform identity in response to others’ reactions
Context collapse
“flattens multiple audiences into one”
Authenticity
true to one’s self; “constantly changes, and … authentic or inauthentic differ contextually”
Networked audience
“real and potential viewers for digital content that exist within a larger social graph”