Modern Meeting Notes

These notes from Al Pittampalli’s (2015) Read This Before Our Next Meeting.

See my related Collaboration and Meetings pages.

Chapter 1. [Too many bad meetings]

Chapter 2. [Compromise and complacency]

Traditional meetings create a culture of compromise

Instead of a meeting structure that demands that we make and defend strong decisions, the broken meeting system we’ve adopted enables us to pass off responsibility too easily.

Traditional meetings kill our sense of urgency

What’s not a meeting?

A conversation is a real-time dialogue between two people; it’s not a meeting.

A group work session is exactly what it sounds like; it’s not a meeting. It’s real work done simultaneously with other team members, intra-team and often ad hoc.

Brainstorms are magical sessions specifically designed for generating lots of ideas.

Chapter 3. The eight principles of modern meetings

  1. The modern meeting doesn’t make decisions. Leaders do.

    If you want my input before you make your preliminary decision, you’ll have to get it from me personally.

  2. The modern meeting has two primary functions: conflict and coordination

  3. The modern meeting moves fast and ends on schedule

  4. The modern meeting limits the number of attendees

    Every member of any meeting should ask him-or herself these questions:

    • Will I be able to function if I read about the meeting after it’s over?
    • If I am giving the decision we’re discussing in advance, can I give my opinion in advance?
    • Do I add any value by sitting in the meeting without participating?
    • Am I attending symbolically, or simply as a way to demonstrate my power?

    If you have no strong opinion, have no interest in the outcome, and are not instrumental for any coordination that needs to take place, we don’t need you. From now on, if you’re invited to a meeting where you don’t belong, please don’t attend.

  5. The modern meeting rejects the unprepared

    If someone comes unprepared, cancel the meeting or hold it without him. In exchange for your preparation, we promise you an intense, very short meeting where something actually gets done.

    If someone comes and doesn’t participate, don’t invite her to the next meeting. This is not high school; we strive to be a world-class organization. We can’t tolerate your unpreparedness anymore. Unprepared participants are dead-weight.

    Sometimes the worst offenders are our top executives. They stroll into the meeting room, empty-handed, waiting to be briefed if they were the king. But they’re not. In the Modern Meeting, the decision is king. All hail the king.

  6. The modern meeting produces committed action plans

    an action plan should include: what actions are we committed to, who was responsible for each action, and when will those actions be completed?

  7. The modern meeting refuses to be informational. Reading memos is mandatory

    Of course, all have to agree on a pact: We’ll cancel the informational meetings, but you must commit to reading the memos. We all have to treat this agreement very seriously. If we don’t read the memo, the pact is broken, and the informational meeting is inevitable. It takes only a few individuals to falter for the entire system of trust to crumble.

    The Modern Meeting requires that you don’t dribble your thoughts in an endless series of instant messages and emails. No, you have to share your thoughts in coherent, cogent documents. These must be complete thoughts that are actually worth reading and responding to.

  8. The modern meeting works only alongside a culture of brainstorming.

Chapter 4. You must decide

Chapter 5. The modern meeting standard

Chapter 6. Frequently asked questions about the modern meeting