Geek knowing: From FAQ to feminism 101

Joseph Reagle

How I got here Compass Study

WikiChix

Wikichix Wikimania 2010 (Millosh) 1

Effect of gap?

  • Few women contributors to Wikipedia.

Why the gap?

Free as in sexist?

  1. some geek identities can be narrow and unappealing;
  2. open communities are especially susceptible to difficult people; and,
  3. the ideas of freedom and openness can be used to dismiss concerns and rationalize the gender gap as a matter of preference and choice. (Reagle2013fas)

What to do?

Geek Feminism

Investigating GF

  • geek knowing
  • “fake” geek girls
  • Comment: Likers, Haters, and Manipulators in the Age of the Web

Geek knowing

Outline

  • Definitions
  • Lexicons
    • FAQ
    • documentation, RTFM, trolls
    • alpha geek, grok
    • 101; derailing; alienation

Definitions

Geek knowing

  • self-documentation
  • sharing
  • self-reliance
  • jargon/cyberlanguage (Gibbs2006lc)

Obligation to know

Extant community members expect newcomers to acquaint themselves with well-established knowledge.

Stature

The extent to which one groks.

Geek feminism (theory)

A type of feminism – as distinct from liberal, postmodern, and radical feminisms – that acknowledges the concerns of feminism while preserving a commitment to geek identity (Bucholtz2002gf).

Geek feminism (praxis)

  • “Female geeks,” Slashdot (Skud1998ffg)
  • “Geek chicks: Second thoughts,” Freshmeat; (Skud2000gcs)
  • Geek Feminism Wiki (2008)
  • Geek Feminism Blog (2009)

Lexicon venn

FAQ

A compendium of accumulated lore, posted periodically to high-volume newsgroups in an attempt to forestall such questions… This lexicon itself serves as a good example of a collection of one kind of lore, although it is far too big for a regular FAQ posting. Examples: “What is the proper type of NULL?” and “What’s that funny name for the `#’ character?” are both Frequently Asked Questions. Several FAQ lists refer readers to this file. (Raymond1993jf)

Documentation

If we do not document, we cannot learn from our history, and are doomed to repeat it. The fact that one must document, document, document is ingrained in my psyche… It is almost impossible for me to understand a world where documentation does not exist… We need short concise information for people starting out, but there are also a lot of finnicky details you don’t even WANT to remember, and which we rather write down to look up when needed. (Bruning2008wtc)

Our main tactic is to document things. To some extent this grows out of my original (very personal and individual) reason for starting the GF wiki back in 2008: I was making an effort to learn more about women’s experiences in geek communities and to contextualise that within the framework/jargon that feminism had already developed in non-geek contexts. My tendency when learning something new is to write documentation to help cement the idea in my own mind and to (hopefully) be of use to others in the future. And so, I created the wiki, which has been fairly central to GF since then. (Skud2012tds)

RTFM

RTFM is a comedic, though stern, form of social discipline. It pushes other hackers to learn and code for themselves as well as affirms that effort has been put into documentation – an accessible form of information that benefits the group – but in a way that still requires independent learning..… To give too much aid is to deny the conditions necessary for self-cultivation. (Coleman2013cfe, p. 110-111)

‘RTFM’ is pretty much the geek way of saying you have a responsibility to educate yourself… I like to think the bright pink takes the edge off the abruptness of the (implied) message. (Laugher2012rwt)

Don’t feed the troll

DoNotFeedTroll

A concern troll is a person who participates in a debate posing as an actual or potential ally who simply has some concerns they need answered before they will ally themselves with a cause. In reality they are a critic. Concern trolling in geek feminism communities can result in continual reversion to Feminism 101 discussions in attempts to appease the troll’s concerns, frustrating attempts at more serious discussion. Concern trolls are not always self-aware, they may also view themselves as potential allies who have just, oddly, never met a feminist opinion they liked. (Feminism2013ct)

alpha geek

[from animal ethologists’ alpha male] The most technically accomplished or skillful person in some implied context. “Ask Larry, he’s the alpha geek here.” (Raymond2003jf)

newbie

[orig. from British public-school and military slang variant of `new boy’] A USENET neophyte.

clue

[Usenet: portmanteau, clue + two-by-four] The notional stick with which one whacks an aggressively clueless person.

grok

vt. 1. To understand, usually in a global sense. Connotes intimate and exhaustive knowledge.

Impostor syndrome

Impostor syndrome describes a situation where someone feels like an impostor or fraud because they think that their accomplishments are nowhere near as good as those of the people around them. Usually, their accomplishments are just as good, and the person is applying an unfairly high standard to themself (and not to others). It’s especially common in fields where people’s work is constantly under review by talented peers, such as academia or Open Source Software. (Feminism2013is)

101

And sometimes, those of us with conditions that intersect with our ability to do this work end up burnt out, frustrated, or we lose our patience…. There is, thankfully, a solution to this problem: those people who say, or comment, that they realllly want to learn must take responsibility for their own learning. There are several ways that this can be accomplished, among them lurking on blogs for a while before one starts commenting, reading a site’s archives (and most sites have them!), picking up a book (or two), reading some articles online or off. (Annaham2010gey)

It’s not just that the conversation is different when I have it with women; it’s different when I have it with people that have bothered to do any reading about the topic at all. It’s like if you went to a Python meetup and all people wanted to talk about was “whoa, significant whitespace!”… At some point it’s nice to have a discussion where those things are a given. (Laugher2012rwt)

Derailing

The ironic “Derailing for Dummies” notes:

By insisting you can only learn if they right then and there sacrifice further hours of time going over the same ground they have so often in the past, you may also make them give up and go away altogether, enabling you to win by default. (Derailing2010dd)

Unicorn law

The Unicorn Law is a play on Godwin’s Law. For those who are not familiar with it, Godwin’s Law states “as a Usenet discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1.” In the Unicorn Law it is the probability of a woman in open source talking about being a woman in open source that approaches 1. (Feminism2011ul)

RTFM & PMS

The valence of the exhortation to “read the fucking manual” is gendered: men are able “to tell someone to RTFM without ever being accused of PMS” (Feminism2013mpp).

Venn Lexicon

The obligation to know serves as a defense to simple ignorance and purposeful disruption.

The intersection of geekdom and feminism highlights the obligation to know ethic and furthers the development of the geek feminism identity.

Discussion??

Media credits

Compass Study

"RTFM" for geek feminism Moo cards 1/2

Wikichix Wikimania 2010 (Millosh) 1

DoNotFeedTroll