Open Codex career :: phd :: citation-paralysis

2004 Feb 11 | Citation Paralysis

Lago notes that academia is ruining the Internet for him: upon reading an interesting blog entry, his reflex is to respond with a bibliography of all the relevant readings that should have been done before the entry was posted. I've noted a similar character in my present academic training, and it grates upon me. One of my most frequent complaints takes the form of asking, "where's the white-board?" In most of my previous experiences a knowledge of the literature was very useful. However, at some point we would gather around a white board, define our terms, sketch a model, and thrash out a design or understanding that we were happy with. In the social sciences, it seems, one cannot even think without first burying one's self under a century of literature.

A problem characteristic of the engineering field is the "not invented here" syndrome: engineers are likely to resort to their own designs without first consulting the field. Yet, I find myself wishing I had that sort of problem again as I feel myself growing trapped in a morass of unimaginative citation.

this entry posted to career/phd;
comments (0)






Name:


E-mail:


URL:


Comment:


NoSpam Magic Word:
The opposite of closed (the first word of this blog's title) is?

Open Communities, Media, Source, and Standards XML

by Joseph Reagle

powered by pyblosxom


reagle.org

What I'm reading online (blogroll)


Categories

Archives